Japan's Atomic Bomb Projects

Projects plural!  I had no idea about these!  They got the U-238 from Germany via submarine and had figured out thermal diffusion of uranium hexaflouride by the time we dropped ours on them!



 
        

I believe it was Sin-Itiro Tomonaga who told Feynman "What took you so long?"  he was expecting the A-bomb to be dropped on Japan at least one year earlier.  Understood everything about it. Indeed, the people at Los Alamos were in fact just screwing around, trying to get things perfect, when 70% of perfect would have worked just fine.  Groves finally had a fit and told them to quit horsing around and get a bomb out to Tinian right away. We were losing 200 men a day at that stage of the war. 

Of course to be fair, the plutonium (Nagasaki) bomb was far more complicated, and instantly made the uranium (Hiroshima) bomb obsolete. Little Boy was so crude that we never even tested it.  We never built another one, although we had already cast the casings for it.

That the Japanese had exploded a uranium bomb left me absolutely gobsmacked.  We built an entire city just to filter UF-6.  Where would the Japanese get the uranium?  Central Africa (The Belgian Congo?)  Hardly. Colorado? *  Don't think so.  And how on earth could they separate the light isotope?  Well, Germany was the answer to #1, and they were using thermal diffusion for #2...no city necessary.  The U.S. Navy had a thermal program but it didn't go anywhere.  It was working, but we already had the Oak Ridge filters up and running, not to say Hanford, Washington for the Plutonium.  Interesting that the Iranians are investing in centrifuges, another method we did not use.

Everybody knows E = mc^2, but that has absolutely nothing to do with how atomic bombs work.  The first lecture everyone got when they arrived at Los Alamos was the fact that electrical potential, not relativity, is the driving concept.  Stop me if you've heard this.

Let's make a uranium nucleus.  Get a proton and hold it in one place.  Now take another proton at infinity, and bring it in to the first at a distance R.  The work you have just done is integral (infinity to R) of k qXq/x^2 dx.  Now take another proton and bring it into the first two.  The work is integral (infinity to R) of k qX2q/x^2 dx.  Then integral (infinity to R) k qX3q/x^2 dx, k being Coulomb's constant.  Keep adding until you bring the 91st proton in.  That is the work you have done in assembling a uranium 92 nucleus.

Now add the 55 integrals for barium 56 and the 37 integrals for strontium 38.  You will see that the uranium work FAR exceeds the work done in assembling the other two.  That's the secret of the atomic bomb.  (Lecture #1, The Los Alamos Primer, by Robert Serber.)

Keeping it really simple, let the first integral have a value of 1.  Then uranium is 1 + 2 + 3 +...+91  = 91X92/2 = 4186 units of work.

Barium clocks in at 1 + 2 + 3 + ... 55 = 55X56/2 = 1540 and strontium is 37X38/2 = 703.  So barium and strontium add up to 1540 + 703 = 2243.

So each reaction unleashes 4186 - 2243 = 1943 units of work (energy).   Of course, all three radii are slightly different, but this is only a first-order approximation after all.  Notice that nowhere does "relativity" explain any of this.

Poor Einstein.  He always protested that he had absolutely nothing to do with the atomic bomb, aside from signing the letter to Roosevelt.  Blame Charles-Augustin Coulomb instead.

Pre-flight rituals before space travel

http://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/why-russian-astronauts-pee-on-a-bus-tire-before-launching-into-space-and-other-preflight-rituals

According to the ESA, Gagarin was on his way to the launch pad in 1961 when he realized he needed to urinate one last time. The bus was stopped, and Gagarin got off, headed to the back-right tire, and relieved himself. As a tribute, each bus trip to the Baikonur launch pad now incorporates a stop, during which crew members pee on the back-right bus tire.
There are quite a few "rituals" cosmonauts have to do.  The tree planting, the door signing, the Russian Orthodox blessing...

Cost of war

http://www.npr.org/2015/07/26/425904134/cost-of-war-veterans-remember-uss-indianapolis-shark-attacks



A Japanese submarine surfaced not far away, saw the silhouette of the ship on the horizon and began tracking it.

Torpedoes were fired and the ship sank in just 12 minutes.

There hadn't been time to get enough life boats into the water, so the survivors clung to life jackets, makeshift rafts and debris, thinking they'd be rescued within a few hours. But after two and a half days in the water, they realized help wasn't coming.

And then things got even worse. Hundreds of sharks had been feeding on those killed in the explosion. But now they turned their attention to the survivors. Thelen saw people get taken by the sharks.

About 900 men survived the torpedo attack after the ship sank. By the time of the rescue only 321 survivors were pulled from the water.

"Years ago, I wouldn't be talking about it to you or anybody else. I wouldn't talk about it for years," Thelen says.

Captain McVay, Captain of the Indianapolis, never got over losing all his men.  Feeling sorry about how the Navy was treating the submarine captain after the war, McVay gave his wife $100 and had her take him shopping for food and presents for his family back in Japan.  Years later McVay committed suicide with his service pistol, with a little plastic sailor clutched in his hand.

The Navy, humiliated by this fiasco, tried to indict the submarine captain for a war crime!  On the stand, the captain said that the U.S. Navy plowed the sea as if they were on streets.  The captain said he simply positioned his sub athwart one and just waited.  Didn't have to wait too long.  Sure enough, there came the Indianapolis.

The Japanese had the very best submarines and absolutely one of the great weapons of WWII...the Long Lance torpedo.  Far superior to anything we, or even the Germans, had.  Why the Japanese used their huge subs mostly for cargo and evacuation and not more offensively is a mystery.

The longer the Japanese captain was on the stand, the more embarrassed the Navy became.  They absolved him of a war crime (just doing his job!) and kicked him out.  That is when McVay gave his wife the $100 to spend on the captain's shopping spree, a man for whom he bore no ill will whatsoever.  He knew the captain faced poverty and hardship back home, his profession dissolved.  From one professional to another.  That would be much more than $1500 today, and surely had to have made a difference to the captain's family in the lean year of 1946.  

McVay, deep down, somehow blamed himself; never the captain.

See also Quint's Indianapolis speech from the movie Jaws: